Morrison Mahoney Partner Bill Smart (Manchester Partner) who obtained a defense verdict after a three-day legal malpractice and consumer fraud trial in Burlington, Vermont, Chittenden County Superior Court, Civil Division. The underlying case involved allegations among siblings of undue influence in obtaining a power of attorney that was allegedly used to sell their father’s home shortly before his death from complications of dementia. Plaintiff claimed that his attorney was negligent in bringing the case in the Civil Division, rather than Probate, where it was dismissed for lack of standing. Our client was ultimately forced to withdraw when the plaintiff became dissatisfied, seeking to withhold payment and place unreasonable limits and restrictions on his representation. The defense argued, among other things, that the law of standing and its application to the facts was uncertain; that our client exercised reasonable professional judgment in recommending the forum and approach that he felt was most advantageous to the client; that his withdrawal was justified under the circumstances; and that it did not cause the plaintiff any harm.
This is the third defense verdict in three states for Bill in 2026, including two med mal defense verdicts, one in Maine and one in New Hampshire.

